Q:
When Imam recites Ayate Durood after Jama'at the followers (Muqtadi)
priase Durood aloud. Due to this some people say that since you
say durood aloud you should also say Aamin aloud after Surahe Fatiha.
So what is the Shara'i Verdict on such people. Some people do not
say Aameen at Imam's Dua but they say their own duas quietly. So
the followers (Muqtadi) should say their own dua or say Aameen on
Imam's Dua?
A: If Muqtadis praise Durood or say Ameen with such intensity
that it breaks the concentration of other people who are still praying
Namaz then it is definately not allowed. If some one does that then
it is given that he should be stoped forcefully, such is mentioned
in Fatawa-e-Rizvia in part three on page 596. Therefore if they
(who question loudness) say because of this reason then they are
right (on Haq) but if no one is praying Namaz at those times than
it is permissible to be aloud.
Dua is definately Amre Mehmood (likeable deed). However performed,
it is allowed. ALLAH Ta'ala says 1*. But is better to say Aameen
at Imam's Dua than perform Dua alone. Because if mutiple people
would say Aameen at Imam's Dua then Dua will be Aqrab Baqabool (better
chances to come true). Alahazrat Imam Ahmad Raza Muhadis-e-Brelvi
radiallah anhu writes,"There is blessing in Jama'at and Dua
of a group of Musims is Aqrab Baqabool.
Scholars mention that wherever there are 40 True Muslims gathered
among them one is a Wali (ALLAH Tala's beloved) for sure. (better
chances to come true). Fatawa-e-Rizvia, Book 9, Part one, Page 157.
Allah Ta'ala Knows the best.
1*
Part
24,Soorah Momin, Ayah 60